In Scoresheet playoffs, we use stats through the scheduled end of the major league season. However, we weigh the final four weeks of stats more heavily, and you must make any playoff lineup decisions before then, so it's somewhat like making a lineup during the regular season. Also, playing time limits in the playoffs are determined solely by a player's playing time in the majors during those final four weeks. More precise details are below.
In 2025, the final four weeks are Sept. 1 (Labor Day in the U.S.) through Sept. 28. If there are a few MLB makeup or tie-breaker games played after Sept. 28, they will not count in Scoresheet, either for playing time limits or stats used. The deadline for playoff lineups is the start of the first MLB game on Sept. 1, the same as the trade deadline, and the week 24 lineup deadline.
We multiply each player's MLB stats from the last four weeks by 3.49, and then add his MLB stats from before that to get his statistics that we base each playoff series on. The effect is that for a player with the same playing time per week in the majors all year, his playoff performance will be 40% based on his MLB performance in the last four weeks of the year, and 60% based on his MLB performance before that. Players who mostly play in the final four weeks in MLB will have those stats matter more than 40%, and players who play less in MLB for the final four weeks will have those stats matter less than 40%. All stats are based on a player's major league performance, not his Scoresheet numbers, and luck balancing starts over with each playoff series.
Playoff series are each best of seven games. In each series, hitters are limited to 40% of their MLB plate appearances during the final four weeks, and pitchers are limited to 45% of their MLB innings pitched during the final four weeks. A pitcher can only start a playoff game if he started a game in the majors in the final four weeks, and can start two playoff games in a series if he started at least three games in the majors in the final four weeks. If a player is injured for the entire final four weeks, he won't play at all in the Scoresheet playoffs.
Starting in mid-August, your lineup card page will have a link to create a separate lineup to be used only in the playoffs. If you don't submit a playoff-only lineup before the above deadline, we'll just use your regular week 24 lineup for the playoffs. If you do create a playoff-only lineup, it won't erase or change your regular season lineup; the regular season and playoff-only lineups are kept entirely separate. You can keep turning in regular season lineup changes for weeks 25-27 as usual, and you can keep changing and resubmitting a playoff-only lineup until its deadline.
A four-man pitching rotation is used in the playoffs (starts are not scattered like in the regular season). So on a playoff-only lineup, you'll begin by reducing your starting rotation from five pitchers to four. Then your top listed pitchers who can start twice will pitch games 1 and 5, 2 and 6, and 3 and 7. Pitcher(s) who can only start once will start at the end of your four-man rotation.
If you need a pitcher pulled from the bullpen to start, then the regular Scoresheet procedures apply - the first pitcher listed in your bullpen that had at least one MLB start in the last four weeks of the major league season will be used (ignoring the Inning and vs.R/L columns). If one of your listed starting pitchers does not get a start during the last four weeks of the major league season, we will drop him to the bullpen for the playoffs, with an earliest inning of 1, a hook of 3, and a reliever rank of 5 versus both left and right handed batters.
The divisions and number of wild-card teams in your league is shown on your league page at the end, above the Season Schedule, starting after the final preseason draft. For standard 10-team leagues, there are two divisions and one wild-card team, for standard 12-team leagues there are three divisions and one wild-card team, and for standard 20-team leagues (standard BLs) there are four divisions and two wild-card teams. For private leagues, if the configuration on your league page is incorrect, please let us know!
Division winners are normally seeded above wild-card teams, including for byes and home field advantage. For example, in standard 10-team leagues with two divisions and one wild card team, the division winner with the better record gets a bye, while the division winner with the worse record plays the wild card team in Round 1 of the playoffs. The only exception is leagues with three divisions and exactly one wild card team. In that case, in Round 1 the top division winner plays the playoff team with the worst won-lost record, whether that team is a wild card team or not. In general, the best seeded teams either get byes in Round 1, or are paired against the worst seeded teams each round.
Tied playoff teams are ranked by head to head records, or run differential if necessary. If the tie only matters for playoff seeding or choosing a division winner, then this ranking is simply used for these teams. If the tie matters for which teams make the playoffs, seven game series are first played among the tied teams (using this ranking to determine matchups) to determine which team(s) advance to the regular playoffs. Such tie breaking series will use the same rules as our normal playoff series, and will be played (and results included) with the normal playoff results.
If there are three teams tied for one playoff berth, the team with the best ranking among the three teams will get a bye while the other two teams play a best of seven series, and then the winner of that series will play another best of seven series against the team that had the bye. If three teams are tied for two wild card berths, the team with the best ranking gets one of the berths, and the other two teams play a best of seven series to determine who gets the second playoff spot.
Note the first step is to determine division winners, who always make the playoffs. So if three teams are tied, with two of them tied for a division crown, while the third is from a different division but tied with those two teams for the only available wild card spot, first the program plays a series to determine who wins the division. Then a series is played between the loser of that series and the third tied team, to determine who gets the wild card spot.